The answer to 'why is my shut-off valve overflowing' is that the shut-off valve itself may be faulty or damaged, causing it to leak water. This can happen due to normal wear and tear over time, or if the valve was not properly installed or maintained.
Some common symptoms of an overflowing shut-off valve include water leaking from the valve, the sound of running water, or water pooling around the valve. If left unchecked, this can lead to water damage in your home.